Who Makes Buffalo Trace Cigars, per 2021 Reports
As reported at its 2021 launch, the Buffalo Trace cigar was made at General Cigar Dominicana for a collaboration between a cigar retailer and Buffalo Trace Distillery. Current production, availability and blend are not verified.
Who Makes Buffalo Trace Cigars
Cigar Dojo, Man of Many and The Daily Pour all reported in 2021 that Cigars International collaborated with Buffalo Trace Distillery on the cigar. For retailer context, see our guide to Cigars International ownership. All three reports named General Cigar Dominicana in the Dominican Republic as the maker.
Cigar Dojo reported that the collaboration marked the launch of two Cigars International stores in Florida. In our comparison of the three 2021 reports, we found that all three name General Cigar Dominicana as the maker, and that Man of Many and The Daily Pour both say the cigar is neither infused nor barrel-aged. Only Cigar Dojo provides an independent tasting. The blend details reported at launch are in the table below.
What Is in the Blend
Cigar Dojo's 2021 specifications describe the Toro's wrapper, binder, filler and factory. The reports do not establish whether those specifications remain current.
| Part | As reported in 2021 |
|---|---|
| Wrapper | Ecuadorian Sumatra, according to Cigar Dojo |
| Binder | Brazilian Arapiraca, according to Cigar Dojo |
| Filler | Tobacco from the Dominican Republic and Nicaragua, according to Cigar Dojo |
| Factory | General Cigar Dominicana in the Dominican Republic, according to Cigar Dojo |
Man of Many's 2021 account also names Dominican piloto cubano among the fillers. The press release quoted by Cigar Dojo says only that the cigar was "Handcrafted in the Dominican Republic." It does not provide the leaf-by-leaf breakdown in the table.
Man of Many and The Daily Pour quote a Cigars International listing that promises cedar, cashews and leather, with hints of vanilla and spice. That wording is retailer sales copy quoted in the 2021 reports. We could not open the retailer's product page, so the listing cannot establish the current blend or availability.
Not Infused or Barrel-Aged
Man of Many and The Daily Pour reported in 2021 that the Buffalo Trace cigar was neither infused nor aged in Buffalo Trace barrels. The press release quoted by Cigar Dojo instead describes a cigar blended to pair with the bourbon.
Cigar Dojo's reviewer noticed a dry oak flavor near the end of the Toro. That tasting note does not change the 2021 reporting about barrel aging. If you want a cigar whose tobacco was aged in bourbon barrels, the reported Buffalo Trace blend does not meet that description.
How Independent Reviewers Rated It
Cigar Dojo's November 2021 review covers one size, the Toro, tasted by one reviewer. Its stated core flavors were medium-roast coffee, leather, black pepper and oak. Cigar Dojo rated the profile medium-plus for flavor and strength, and medium for body.
The reviewer reported that black pepper built as the cigar progressed. Cigar Dojo described the profile as harsh once pepper and leather overpowered the background notes. Its listed drawbacks were pepper covering all but the core flavors, little complexity and a need for a few touch-ups. The reviewer also called the cigar consistent and gave its purchase recommendation as "Buy a couple and give 'em a shot."
The reviewer tried the Toro alone and with Buffalo Trace bourbon, then wrote that the pairing "mark was missed." Cigar Dojo suggested a sweeter bourbon, añejo tequila or dark rum as a better match. Its account says the bourbon's caramel and vanilla did not do enough to tame the cigar's pepper.
Man of Many and The Daily Pour quote the retailer listing calling the cigar "incredibly balanced." That is Cigars International's sales wording as reproduced by those publications. Cigar Dojo's Toro review is the only independent tasting in the available sources, so it cannot establish how every size or a current production cigar would taste.
Pairing With Bourbon
Our cigar and whiskey pairing guide recommends matching the intensity of the cigar and whiskey. It pairs a medium cigar with standard bourbon and points to Connecticut or Maduro wrappers when you want cream, nut or cocoa notes alongside bourbon's caramel and vanilla. That is general pairing advice. It is not a judgment about the Buffalo Trace blend.
Cigar Dojo reported a different result with the 2021 Buffalo Trace Toro. Its reviewer found that the bourbon's caramel and vanilla did not tame the cigar's pepper. If flavor matters more to you than the Buffalo Trace name, our pairing guide gives you another way to choose a cigar for bourbon.
Who This Is Not For
The Buffalo Trace cigar is a poor fit if you expect bourbon-infused tobacco or barrel aging, based on the 2021 reports from Man of Many and The Daily Pour. If you need a cigar you can be sure is currently sold, choose one with confirmed availability instead. Current availability of Buffalo Trace cigars is not verified here.
Cigar Dojo called the 2021 Toro medium-plus in strength. If you are looking specifically for a full-strength cigar, use our cigar strength guide to choose by strength rather than by the bourbon name. This page is for adults 21 and over.
What Would Change Our Answer
A newer account of the blend, producer or distribution could change the 2021 description. Newer independent tastings could also change how much weight to give Cigar Dojo's critical review of one Toro. Neither a current product listing nor a newer independent tasting is established by the sources available here.
If you are considering Buffalo Trace cigars, compare Cigar Dojo's 2021 Toro verdict with the pairing advice above before choosing a cigar.
FAQ
Who makes Buffalo Trace cigars?
Cigar Dojo, Man of Many and The Daily Pour reported in 2021 that General Cigar Dominicana in the Dominican Republic made the Buffalo Trace cigar. It was a Cigars International collaboration with Buffalo Trace Distillery. Its current producer and availability are not verified here.
Are Buffalo Trace cigars infused with bourbon?
No, according to the 2021 reports from Man of Many and The Daily Pour. Both also reported that the cigar was not aged in Buffalo Trace barrels.
Are Buffalo Trace cigars made in Kentucky?
No. Cigar Dojo, Man of Many and The Daily Pour reported in 2021 that the cigar was made at General Cigar Dominicana in the Dominican Republic.
Are Buffalo Trace cigars any good?
Cigar Dojo's 2021 Toro reviewer found recognizable core flavors but criticized the building pepper, limited complexity and bourbon pairing. That is one reviewer's assessment of one size, and newer independent reviews are not established here.
Are Buffalo Trace cigars still available?
Current availability is not verified. The available reports describe the cigar at its 2021 launch and do not establish whether it is still made or sold.