How to Put Out a Cigar and Use an Ashtray
To put out a cigar properly, set it down on the rest of an ashtray and let it go out on its own. At Humidorist, we compared what two cigar retailers publish on putting a cigar out so the methods sit in one table.
Refined Traditions says crushing a burning cigar releases unpleasant odors, and Swiss Cuban Cigars also says to let it go out on its own.
If you smoke regularly, buy a proper cigar ashtray with wide rests. If you are away from home, a snuffer is the other option if you own one.
Let It Go Out on Its Own
Setting the cigar down in an ashtray without pressing down on the foot is the method Swiss Cuban Cigars and Refined Traditions both recommend. Once you place the cigar on a resting groove, the burning embers extinguish naturally within a few minutes.
Refined Traditions says crushing a burning cigar releases unpleasant odors and is poor etiquette.
Knowing when to stop smoking also helps preserve the overall experience. Swiss Cuban Cigars says to let the cigar go out on its own once you are tired of the flavor, with about 2 to 4 inches left. Our guide on how to smoke a cigar says to stop near the band with one to two inches left, so the two guides differ.
If you need to pause your smoke temporarily rather than discard it, leave the cigar resting flat on the stirrup. Swiss Cuban Cigars recommends not leaving a resting cigar in open air for more than 30 minutes before resuming. If you know you cannot return within that brief window, let the cigar extinguish fully and decide whether to trim and save it.
How to Use a Cigar Ashtray
A proper cigar ashtray features wide grooves and a deep collection bowl. Swiss Cuban Cigars notes that the best cigar ashtrays have long surfaces to rest the cigar flat.
Our guide on how to smoke a cigar explains that you should let the ash column build to about an inch before clearing it.
Swiss Cuban Cigars says ceramic, cast iron, stainless steel and crystal are all safe for putting out cigars, though ceramic and crystal can break if dropped. For specific product picks, bowl depths, and multi-cigar setups, read our roundup of the best cigar ashtrays.
When smoking in social settings such as private lounges, clubs, or a friend's patio, ashtray etiquette matters. In clubs or shops, staff may empty ashtrays. If you are visiting a home or an unfamiliar venue and see no obvious place to put your nub, politely ask the host or venue staff for an ashtray. Formal settings often have specific rules regarding where cigars may be smoked and how waste is collected. Calling ahead or asking about local etiquette prevents misunderstandings before you light up.
Methods for Putting Out a Cigar Compared
Refined Traditions names three acceptable methods, and stubbing a cigar out is the one to avoid.
The table below outlines the three accepted methods and the one to avoid, based on published guidance from Refined Traditions and Swiss Cuban Cigars.
| Method | When to Use It | Result | Caution |
|---|---|---|---|
| Let it go out on its own | Standard smoking sessions in a lounge, patio, or home | Embers die within a few minutes without foul odor | Let the tip cool before you handle it (Swiss Cuban Cigars) |
| Cigar snuffer | When you own one and want a clean, odor-free finish (Refined Traditions) | Cuts off the oxygen supply to the burning end | Needs a snuffer on hand (Refined Traditions says snuffers were more common in the past) |
| Liquid dunk | When it must go out quickly and neither of the other two methods is possible (Refined Traditions) | Extinguishes the burning cherry instantly | Messy and not dignified (Refined Traditions), so dispose of the extinguished cigar properly |
| Stubbing out | Not recommended under any standard circumstances | Releases unpleasant odors | Poor etiquette (Refined Traditions) |
Refined Traditions describes a snuffer as an accessory resembling a small candle holder. To use it, stand the cigar upright inside the holder with the burning cherry end pointing down. Standing the cigar cherry end down deprives the burning end of oxygen. Snuffers were more common in the past but remain useful.
Liquid serves as a last resort when a cigar must go out immediately and no snuffer is near. Refined Traditions notes that dunking the burning foot directly into a container of liquid snuffs out the fire instantly. Outdoors where no cup of water is available, Refined Traditions mentions that even a small puddle of saliva can suffice in a pinch.
Stubbing out a cigar should be avoided entirely. Crushing a burning cigar releases unpleasant odors and is poor etiquette.
What to Use When You Have No Cigar Ashtray
For a single cigar, a deep dish made of ceramic, cast iron, stainless steel or crystal does the job, since Swiss Cuban Cigars lists those as safe materials. If you are a guest, politely ask the host or venue for an ashtray. A snuffer is the other option when no dish is nearby.
Saving a Half-Smoked Cigar
Our guide on how to store cigars says a partially smoked cigar usually loses most of its character within hours, so saving one works best when you will smoke it soon.
The process begins by letting the cigar extinguish on its own on an ashtray rest. Never stub or crush the foot, because crushing releases unpleasant odors. Swiss Cuban Cigars says to cut about half an inch behind the ash line.
The sources disagree on humidors. Refined Traditions says not to put a half-smoked cigar back in a desktop humidor. Swiss Cuban Cigars says that if you use a humidor, you should wrap the half-smoked cigar in cellophane. Our storage guide warns that a lit or recently lit cigar in a humidor with fresh cigars taints the box.
Retailers and guides conflict on exactly how long a partially smoked cigar will stay fresh:
- Swiss Cuban Cigars recommends sealing the trimmed cigar tight inside a plastic bag and finishing it within 24 hours. They state that waiting longer than 48 hours can result in a stale, unappealing taste.
- Our own storage guide points out that a partially smoked cigar loses most of its character within hours, recommending that you relight within about the hour for acceptable results.
Given these differing timeframes, treat the shorter window as the safer rule if flavor quality is your priority. Swiss Cuban Cigars says to let the cigar return to room temperature before relighting it. If it feels brittle, Swiss Cuban Cigars says to moisten the tip with your breath or wet it with your finger.
Disposing of a Cigar Safely
Swiss Cuban Cigars says to dispose of the nub in a fire-resistant container to avoid accidents.
Let the tip cool before you handle it. If you are cleaning up indoors, Swiss Cuban Cigars recommends placing the cool nub inside a plastic sandwich bag before dropping it into an indoor trash can. Sealing the nub inside a bag helps contain the smell (Swiss Cuban Cigars).
Swiss Cuban Cigars adds these disposal points:
- If you smoke frequently on a patio or deck, keep a dedicated metal trash can outside or in your garage for cigar ashes and nubs.
- While pouring water over a nub is not required if the cigar has cooled naturally, Swiss Cuban Cigars notes you may do so at home as an extra safety measure before tossing it into outdoor refuse.
- Always dispose of extinguished cigars in a fire-resistant container to avoid fire hazards.
- Never flush cigar nubs down a toilet. Swiss Cuban Cigars warns that cigar nubs can clog the toilet.
Our Takeaway
Rest the cigar flat on a deep ashtray's rest and let the cherry go out on its own. A snuffer is a clean alternative if you own one, and liquid is the messy last resort when the cigar must go out at once (Refined Traditions). If you smoke regularly, buy a proper cigar ashtray with wide channels, and improvise with ceramic or metal dishes only for an occasional single cigar.
This recommendation changes if a venue has its own rules for cigars, so ask the host or staff before you light up (Swiss Cuban Cigars).
FAQ
Do you need an ashtray for cigars?
If you smoke regularly, yes. Swiss Cuban Cigars says to use a deep ashtray designed for cigars, with a long surface to rest the cigar flat, to stop ash and tobacco spilling. For a single cigar, a deep dish made of ceramic, cast iron, stainless steel or crystal works.
How do you ash a cigar properly?
To ash a cigar properly, let the ash reach about an inch, then roll it off gently against the edge of the ashtray. Do not flick it like a cigarette.
Why not ash a cigar too often?
Our guide on how to smoke a cigar says a longer ash helps insulate the burn and keep the cigar cool, so let it reach about an inch before you roll it off.
Can you relight a cigar?
Yes, you can relight a cigar if it goes out while you are smoking or if you pause for a short duration. Let the foot go out naturally, then follow the relighting steps in our guide on how to smoke a cigar. If you plan to save the cigar for another day, cut half an inch behind the ash line and store it isolated from fresh cigars, keeping in mind that flavor quality drops significantly as time passes.
To set up an optimal smoking space at home, explore our buying guide for the best cigar ashtrays to choose a durable, deep-dish model with wide rests for your collection.