Do Box Pressed Cigars Taste Different From Round Cigars?
Perdomo says, on the Perdomo Podcast episode on box pressed cigars, that its box pressed cigars taste the same as its round cigars. Pressing changes how a cigar feels in the mouth, though, and Perdomo says it can change a smoker's perception of the blend. Holt's Cigar Company reports claims about draw, burn and flavor consistency that do not establish a universal taste difference.
Neither source cites a matched test of round and pressed cigars with the same blend and dimensions. If you are comparing shapes, judge the particular cigars in front of you rather than expecting every box pressed cigar to taste different.
Do Box Pressed Cigars Taste Different?
Perdomo's answer for its own cigars is no: Perdomo says it designs a blend's flavor before deciding whether to make the cigar round or box pressed. Nick and Nicholas Perdomo say they adjust construction to preserve the intended taste when a cigar will be pressed. That is a manufacturer's account of its own process. It does not settle the question for every cigar.
The Perdomos also say shape affects draw, combustion and the overall smoking experience. In their words, changing the shape can give consumers "a different perception of the blend." A cigar can therefore feel different to smoke even when its maker intends the blend to taste the same.
Holt's gives a different account of the possible smoking differences. Its article says box pressed cigars are generally credited with a slower burn and a looser draw. It adds that some claim more consistent flavor. Holt's qualifies those claims: much depends on the blend and the cigarmaker's quality control. More consistent flavor is also a different claim from a stronger flavor or a different flavor profile.
Neither account supplies a same-blend, same-size head-to-head test. For a closer look at the role of tobacco and blending, see why cigar brands taste different.
What Box Pressed Means
A box pressed cigar begins as a round cigar and is compressed into a squarer shape, according to Holt's. The finished shape can have gently flattened sides or sharply defined corners. Box pressing describes that change in shape. It does not identify the cigar's blend or dimensions.
Holt's describes two ways to make the shape. In the more common method it reports, round cigars are packed tightly into boxes. The boxes are stacked in a hand-cranked press, and pressure increases gradually as the cigars conform to the space inside. The result has a pressed appearance without being perfectly square.
The second method is trunk-pressing. Holt's says each cigar is clamped between wooden slats for 30 minutes to 12 hours and rotated so all four sides receive pressure. This produces sharper corners than the box method. Holt's says the work takes more care because the wrapper can split.
Shape and size answer different questions. A pressed cigar can be described by its length and ring gauge just as a round cigar can. The cigar sizes guide explains those measurements. When comparing two cigars, keep the dimensions in view alongside the shape.
How Perdomo Builds a Box Pressed Cigar
Perdomo says it changes the construction of its box pressed cigars to account for pressure on the wrapper and filler. The Perdomos describe the pressed cigar as slightly lighter in fill than a round one, giving it some softness. They call it "properly filled" rather than underfilled.
In Perdomo's account, a pressed cigar needs air passages after compression. The Perdomos say filling one as they fill a round cigar could leave it unable to draw. They also say too much fill could cause wrappers to split during pressing, even if the cigar would draw.
Perdomo says it selects wrappers from thicker primings for structural strength. Perdomo says it keeps the higher-priming tobaccos in its blends rather than weakening a blend to make pressing easier. These are Perdomo's descriptions of how it makes its cigars. They are not specifications for every box pressed cigar.
Perdomo also describes a pressing schedule distinct from Holt's trunk-pressing account. Perdomo says each cigar sits in a custom tray for 24 hours, with 12 hours of pressing on each side. Holt's reports a range of 30 minutes to 12 hours for trunk-pressing individual cigars between slats. The two accounts describe different practices.
Perdomo favors a soft press with gentler edges. Nick Perdomo says he finds sharply pressed corners uncomfortable, while acknowledging that other smokers have liked an aggressive press. His preference helps explain why "box pressed" alone does not tell you how sharp a cigar's corners will feel.
How Box Pressed and Round Cigars Smoke Differently
The reported differences concern construction, mouth feel, draw and burn. The sources do not give a measured result for a matched round and pressed pair.
| Style | How it is made | What the sources report on feel, draw and burn | Cutter note | Source |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Round | Rolled round. Perdomo says its round cigars get two presses and carry slightly more tobacco | Firmer in feel, per Perdomo. Lips can fully clasp the shape, per Holt's | Standard guillotine fits | Perdomo, Holt's |
| Soft box press | Rolled round, packed in boxes and pressed gradually in a hand-cranked press, per Holt's. Perdomo says it presses its cigars in custom trays for 24 hours, 12 per side | Slower burn, looser draw and, some claim, more consistent flavor, per Holt's. Softer feel and no taste difference in its own cigars, per Perdomo | Punch or scissors for flat caps. A guillotine may not fit, per Holt's | Holt's, Perdomo |
| Trunk-pressed | Each cigar is clamped between wooden slats for 30 minutes to 12 hours and rotated, per Holt's | Sharp, squared corners, per Holt's. Holt's attributes a cooler draw to box pressed shapes generally | Same box pressed cutting considerations, per Holt's | Holt's |
Neither source cites a test of round and pressed cigars matched for blend and size.
Holt's credits box pressed cigars with a looser draw. It also says lips cannot fully clasp a pressed cigar as they can a round one. Holt's attributes a cooler draw to air entering from outside the cigar as a smoker draws. Those are the retailer article's explanations. Holt's does not supply measurements from a matched comparison.
Perdomo approaches draw through construction. The Perdomos say they use slightly less fill in their pressed cigars so air passages remain after pressing. They warn that using their round-cigar fill could prevent a pressed cigar from drawing. That does not establish that pressing itself either loosens or tightens the draw across cigars. If a particular cigar draws poorly or burns unevenly, use the burn and draw problems guide to assess that cigar.
How to Cut a Box Pressed Cigar
A flat box pressed cap may not fit the opening of a standard guillotine cutter, particularly at a larger ring gauge, according to Holt's. Choose a cutter that accommodates the cap without forcing the cigar into the opening.
- For a flat cap, consider a punch. Holt's says multiple punch cuts can increase airflow. Apply pressure gently because Holt's warns that a flat cap can crack.
- If using cigar scissors, check their opening. Holt's says the blades need to open wide enough for the cigar's ring gauge.
- For a tapered head, a guillotine may work. Holt's says a standard guillotine works on a box pressed Torpedo or Belicoso because the head tapers.
The cutting method depends on the cap and the cutter's opening. The box pressed label alone does not decide it. See how to cut a cigar for the cutting technique and cigar cutter vs punch for the differences between those tools.
Choosing Between Round and Box Pressed
Choose by how the cigar feels at your lips and whether your cutter fits its cap. Perdomo says neither shape is necessarily better and describes its softer box press as comfortable because lips run from side to side. Holt's describes a different mouth contact: lips do not fully clasp a box pressed shape. Neither account makes comfort a rule for everyone.
Presentation may also affect a preference. Perdomo says the band on its 20th Anniversary cigar sits flat when the cigar is pressed, and the pressed cigars line up neatly in a box. The Perdomos say round cigars look good too. Those details explain a maker's shape choice without making a claim about taste.
A highly rated pressed cigar is a reason to consider that cigar. It is not evidence that pressing improved it. Holt's reports that Cigar Aficionado named Arturo Fuente Don Carlos Eye of the Shark, My Father Le Bijou 1922 Torpedo Box Press, Padron Family Reserve #45 Maduro, Flor de las Antillas Toro, Oliva Serie V Melanio Figurado and Alec Bradley Prensado Churchill its number-one Cigar of the Year in their respective years. Holt's also cites top-five placements for Ashton VSG, La Aroma de Cuba Mi Amor and Rocky Patel Sun Grown Maduro. Those rankings do not compare each cigar with a round version of the same blend and size.
For readers choosing between round and pressed versions, Perdomo's reported answer is that its intended taste stays the same. Holt's reports possible differences in draw and burn, plus a qualified claim about flavor consistency. The accounts support choosing a specific cigar for its feel and construction rather than expecting a universal taste difference. A matched same-blend, same-size comparison, or a maker reporting a flavor change caused by pressing, could change that answer.
Where Box Pressing Came From
Holt's says the origin of box pressing is unclear. It traces the practice to pre-embargo Cuba but does not identify the first brand to press cigars. Holt's presents several proposed reasons as speculation: fitting cigars into boxes, keeping them from rolling off a table and limiting rolling during transport.
Nick Perdomo tells a school-books story he says he heard from his father. In that family account, a girl at the H. Upmann factory placed books on rolled cigars to keep them from falling off a table. A manager noticed the flattened cigars and tried one. It is Perdomo family lore, and none of the cited sources verifies it.
For the shape's later popularity, Holt's points to Padron 1964 Anniversary. Holt's says its box pressed profile attracted attention during the 1990s Cigar Boom and that other brands followed. That account of popularity does not resolve the older origin stories.
Who This Is Not For
A shape comparison cannot tell you whether one particular cigar will suit you. If your question is about a specific round or pressed cigar, assess its blend, dimensions, cap and how it feels to you. The accounts from Perdomo and Holt's do not supply a taste verdict for every cigar carrying either shape.
A matched test using the same blend and dimensions would make the taste comparison more direct. A maker's documented report that pressing changed the flavor of its own cigar would also change the answer for that cigar. Until then, neither source supports treating the shape as a universal flavor prediction.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are box pressed cigars better?
Neither shape is necessarily better, according to Perdomo. Perdomo recommends going by comfort, while Holt's calls the difference a matter of personal preference. If a flat cap does not fit your cutter, that practical constraint may matter more than the shape's appearance.
Are box pressed cigars softer?
Perdomo says its box pressed cigars feel softer than its round cigars. Perdomo says it fills them slightly lighter to leave room for air passages after pressing. That describes Perdomo's construction. It does not establish how firm every box pressed cigar will feel.
What is a box pressed cigar?
A box pressed cigar is a cigar rolled round and then compressed into a squarer shape, as Holt's describes it. Holt's distinguishes the gentler shape formed by pressing packed boxes from the sharper corners made by trunk-pressing individual cigars.
Are box pressed cigars hand rolled?
Holt's says the cigars in the methods it describes are rolled round before they are pressed. The cited account does not establish the rolling method of every box pressed cigar, so the pressed shape alone does not answer that question for a particular cigar.
What is the difference between box pressed and round cigars?
The visible difference is that a box pressed cigar has flattened sides while a round cigar keeps its round shape. Perdomo reports a softer feel for its pressed cigars. Holt's credits box pressed cigars with a slower burn and looser, cooler draw, with a caveat that blend and quality control matter. To compare shapes for yourself, choose the specific round and pressed cigars you want to assess and start by checking how each cap fits your cutter.